Hotels in Cay Bay Hill

"Loved our stay"

"The only thing we wish we had was entertainment. The hotel was boring. Everything around the pool was closed. The swim up bar, no entertainment at all. It was dead. The only thing was for two nights, they had someone to come in to sing "

"Amazing property "

"We loved every minute! "

"The staff at Oyster Pond were excellent and they provided a good range of free entertainment. The daily happy hours at the bar (buy one/get one free) was great. The outdoor pool was refreshing, with lounge chairs and umbrellas always available. The only drawback is the beach, due to the sargassum (seaweed) there is a smell and it has to be raked daily. If you’re content with the pool, it’s a great place to stay, however if the beach is a must for you, consider staying elsewhere on the Caribbean side."

"Great location very nice accommodations! "

"Kitchen fully equipped. Parking availble. Friendly staff. "

"We went from August 31 to September 6 of 2025 and it was a lot better than we anticipated. The beaches are beyond gorgeous. This hotel is fun. The food is absolutely delicious. Good vibes all around."

"The Plus Studio is large and well appointed. Very comfortable bed. I appreciated the accommodation for my limited walking. The resort offers many amenities. Getting to them can be difficult. Roads are small and not in good condition."