Hotels in Cay Bay Hill

"View was beautiful of the pool and it was central to a beautiful mullet bay and surrounding night life. Easy access to the airport and Maho beach to watch the planes land and take off."

"Dirty room, broken furniture, lazy staff (had to beg for a sheet change - had only 1 in a week), unhelpful front desk staff - overall - worst place we ever stayed at. The cost of this hotel was ridiculous for what we got. So disappointed!!"

"Our first room was not what we thought we had booked. It was far away from main buildings and up a steep hill. There was not a direct view of the water. We asked for a change and the staff accommodated us after one day. The room over looking the beach was great, convenient to everything with a modern kitchen with washer dryer and balcony. "

"Had to request a room change. The picture on your site showed water view but was stuck in a non water room"

"Didn’t use"

"The spa great!"

"Very pretty resort on the Atlantic Ocean. Staff was helpful and kind in almost every way. We had Sasha as our waitress many times in the restaurant and she was pleasant and helpful. Our next trip to St. Marteen will include Oyster Bay Resort."

"It feels like management/ownership is leaving the staff out to dry. One day they had a pipe leak and we couldn’t get any hot water. The icemaker in the refrigerator didn’t work because it wasn’t hooked up and never did get hooked up. Had to TRY and get ice every morning. Apparently ice is like gold there. The room was good and we had a nice view of the ocean. There were a bunch of little things that just added up turn our stay into an average one."

"Beautiful landscaped property with nice balcony overlooking the property. Nice pool and gym and good location on the island."