Hotels near Sunset Beach Shelter Island Heights

"We loved the Menhaden. The staff was beyond friendly and helpful. The hotel provides so many amenities. The hotel is so modern and unique. We would definitely love to stay there again. "

"this place was absolutely beautiful, would definitely recommend staying here. a downtown area is just a little ways away and theres an amazing restaurant within walkable distance. its a beachgoers dream stay!"

"The property is beautiful. Stunning views. Wonderful staff. Rooms are pristine."

"Always a sold stay on Shelter Island"

"Beautiful hotel, steps from everything in Greenport. My room had a lovely view of the harbor where you can watch the Shelter Island ferries come and go all day. The room was beautifully decorated and the shower was amazing. Would have preferred to park in the lot but that was an up charge. Street parking in the off season is doable. Will stay again!"

"How staff was very nice. It was very convenient to walk into town . There were plenty of great restaurants and the wineries were phenomenal. We would definitely go back there. It’s one of our favorite places."

"Beautiful rooms and bar on the property. Great location, easy to walk around town. Cute bikes available for a ride to the beach. "

"Nice, quiet & quaint bed and breakfast near all, friendly staff"

"An absolute gem. Came for a quiet getaway and the perfect storm of calmness. Will is a wonderful host, making sure I was welll taken care of and focusing on every detail. He made sure I was able to check in and reach him during a winter storm and was readily available. The place is wonderful and filled with lots of fireplaces and room amenities that feel spa like and warm. Best night sleep I’ve had in a cloud of pillows and bed, in such a long time. Thank you so much for a wonderful time. "

"Amazing location on beach, with heated pool and super close to town! Beautiful sunsets!"

"Cabin was clean, well appointed and very comfortable. The staff immediately responded at 7am when we called to reset the hot water heater. The Solo fire pit looked very tempting but we did not have the time to enjoy that. will be back!"

"Really enjoyed the comfortable environment. Staff was very helpful. We’ll be back"

"Great staff "

"Everything and everyone was just lovely! Comfortable Welcoming Great restaurant "

"Bed and pillows amazing. Great Location Loved the bikes Beach very close. "

"Beautiful place. Would definitely stay again. Clean room with a wonderful scent oil with all the amenities such as microwave and small fridge. "

"Dawn was exceptional. The location allowed us to get a real feel for the Hamptons"

"Beautiful property, but no restaurant open for lunch, no pool service, no one to answer calls at front desk. Constant marketing notices."