Location
Tucked just a short walk away from the hustle and bustle of the city, the hotel is ideally placed for those who want peace and quiet without having to head for the outskirts.
Room
The rooms are decorated with solid and well-maintained furniture, as well as some lovely works of art (the hotel doubles as an art gallery). We noticed very little noise from other rooms. Our room had a roll-top bath, and a ton of space for moving around, as well as a lovely view out to the Firth of Forth.
According to my spouse, the only thing missing was a shoe horn.
Service
The staff were absolutely magnificent. We were greeted warmly by everyone, and it seemed that no (reasonable) ask was too much. Whether manning the desk or the bar, the staff were happy to chat, share their knowledge of the city, and joyfully critique my taste in whiskies.
Value
This is not a budget hotel. You get what you pay for. That said, it was well worth what we paid.
Overall
The hotel has no gym, but we got plenty of cardio walking to the hotel and up its long staircases.
This hotel is a boutique spot, perfect for those who want a break from the generic mass market approach while discovering Edinburgh and its surrounds.