This hotel was spacious, which is not the norm for a hotel in NYC. The room was very comfortable and clean. The staff was helpful and welcoming. Guest have to ask for house keeping, which is not that big of a deal but I always forgot to ask...
As far as location is concerned, this hotel is very central. You can walk to many NY tourist sites and activities. Sub was is not super close, but if you're doing NY, be prepared to walk.
As a former NYer, midtown is not my favorite place to stay but this location worked for this trip. The price was reasonable. The hotel was great.