Hotels near Shelter Island Beach Haven

Free cancellation options if plans change

Earn rewards on every night you stay

Save more with Member Prices

Check prices for these dates

Tonight

Tomorrow

This weekend

Next weekend

Where to stay near Shelter Island?

Properties are selected based on real traveler reviews and popularity among guests who’ve booked a night near Shelter Island on Hotels.com. These hotels close to Shelter Island consistently deliver on quality, location and traveler experience. Last updated on October 12, 2026.

A large, multi-story hotel with a prominent sign reading "Hotel LBI".

A spacious lounge area with a large screen displaying a welcome message, comfortable seating arrangements, and a decorative sailboat model.

An indoor swimming pool with multiple lanes and lounge chairs, surrounded by large windows and potted plants.

A spacious hotel lobby with a long wooden reception desk, multiple seating areas, and a ceiling with blue lighting.

1. Hotel LBI

Ship Bottom, 9.9 km from Shelter Island

Ryan

CNY1,322

CNY1,515 total

includes taxes & fees

Oct 13 - Oct 14

A hotel with a parking lot and a winding road.

A reception area with a stone wall, a Holiday Inn sign, and a reception desk.

A spacious restaurant with high ceilings, exposed brick walls, and large windows. Tables are arranged in rows, and there is a bar area visible in the background.

An outdoor seating area with wooden benches and a stone fire pit.

2. Holiday Inn Manahawkin/Long Beach Island by IHG

12.5 km from Shelter Island

Jaime

CNY964

CNY1,076 total

includes taxes & fees

Nov 1 - Nov 2

A restaurant with wooden tables and blue and white patterned chairs, a ceiling fan, and a view of the outside.

A modern kitchen with a dining table, a TV mounted on the wall, and a refrigerator.

A covered porch with a white roof, surrounded by flowering plants and a gravel pathway.

A restaurant with wooden tables and chairs, a bar area with a stone counter, and hanging lights.

3. Surf City Hotel

Surf City, 11.4 km from Shelter Island

Christopher

CNY800

CNY917 total

includes taxes & fees

Oct 26 - Oct 27

A large, two-story building with a prominent tower and multiple windows, surrounded by lush greenery and a well-maintained lawn.

A golf course with a clubhouse, surrounded by dense trees and a clear sky.

A modern kitchen with a marble island, wooden chairs, pendant lighting, and a built-in dishwasher.

A spacious banquet hall with round tables and wicker chairs, large windows, and a high ceiling with a chandelier.

4. The Inn at LBI National

8.2 km from Shelter Island

Stephanie

CNY776

CNY1,034 total

includes taxes & fees

Oct 13 - Oct 14

A multi-story hotel with balconies, a parking area, and a view of the sunset.

A reception area with a counter, a phone, and a window with a view of a building outside.

A hotel room with two beds, a desk, a chair, a dresser, and a balcony with a view.

A beach scene with a wooden fence, sandy beach, and a sunset over the ocean.

5. Drifting Sands Oceanfront Hotel

Ship Bottom, 10 km from Shelter Island

Kat

CNY681

CNY949 total

includes taxes & fees

Oct 25 - Oct 26

A beach with a row of large rocks along the shoreline.

A two-story motel with a balcony on the second floor, a flag in front, and a parking lot with cars.

A compact kitchen with a dining table, chairs, a ceiling fan, a refrigerator, and a microwave.

A room with a large window, a table, and chairs.

6. Sea Horse Motel

Brant Beach, 7.6 km from Shelter Island

"I stayed here with my grandaughter and we loved the hotel. It is one e if the few hotels that have a pool in LBI. The pool was great and clean. The location of the hotel was great too! The water pressure in the shower was amazing! There front desk staff were very nice and helpful. We rented a beach umbrella for 5.00 which was great because we forgot to bring one. I would definitely recommend staying here!"

Patricia

CNY1,134

CNY1,266 total

includes taxes & fees

Oct 13 - Oct 14

A wooden building with a sign reading "DECAYS" by the water.

A bedroom with a large window, a bed with red bedding, a lamp, and a bathtub.

A room with a bed, a nightstand, a green chair, a table, and a window overlooking a deck.

A table with a bottle of champagne, two glasses, a vase with a red rose, and a bowl of strawberries.

7. Colonial Inn

20.2 km from Shelter Island

Robert

CNY1,064

CNY1,220 total

includes taxes & fees

Oct 13 - Oct 14

View all properties

Compare popular hotels close to Shelter Island

Property	Property class	Guest rating
Hotel LBI	9.6 Exceptional 1,026 reviews	View
Holiday Inn Manahawkin/Long Beach Island by IHG	9.2 Wonderful 1,001 reviews	View
Surf City Hotel	8.6 Excellent 363 reviews	View
The Inn at LBI National	8.8 Excellent 306 reviews	View
Drifting Sands Oceanfront Hotel	8.2 Very good 1,006 reviews	View

Other landmarks near Shelter Island

A coastal residential area with buildings near the shore and a distant bridge.

Bay Village

9.2/10 (170 reviews)

If you like shopping, take time out to go to Bay Village when in Beach Haven.

See properties

A beach with waves, a sandy shore, and a sailboat in the distance.

Spray Beach

9.2/10 (110 reviews)

If being by the water is a major draw, Spray Beach is a spot you might want to check out, located 1.2 mi (1.9 km) from central Beach Haven. Enjoy the sunset by the shore at Haven Beach, Brighton Beach, and Brant Beach.

See properties

Museum of New Jersey Maritime History

8.6/10 (11 reviews)

Museum of New Jersey Maritime History is 2.2 mi (3.6 km) from central Beach Haven, why not stop by during your stay. Hotels.com travelers also say the area is family-friendly and has lots of nice beaches. If you want to experience more of the culture Beach Haven has to offer, head to Fantasy Island Amusement Park, Surflight Theatre, and Thundering Surf Waterpark.

See properties

Thundering Surf Waterpark

8.6/10 (39 reviews)

Why not give yourself a treat with a trip to Thundering Surf Waterpark, one of the family attractions located 1.9 mi (3 km) from central Beach Haven. Why not take a stroll along the beaches and watch the sunset while you're here? If you have fun at Thundering Surf Waterpark, you'll love Fantasy Island Amusement Park and Settler's Mill Adventure Golf, both a short walk away.

See properties

Settler's Mill Adventure Golf

9.2/10 (17 reviews)

Why not give yourself a treat with a trip to Settler's Mill Adventure Golf, one of the family attractions located 1.8 mi (3 km) from central Beach Haven. Why not take a stroll along the beaches and watch the sunset while you're here? If you have fun at Settler's Mill Adventure Golf, you'll love Thundering Surf Waterpark and Fantasy Island Amusement Park, both a short walk away.

See properties

Fantasy Island Amusement Park

8.8/10 (167 reviews)

Why not give yourself a treat with a trip to Fantasy Island Amusement Park, one of the family attractions located 1.9 mi (3.1 km) from central Beach Haven. Why not take a stroll along the beaches and watch the sunset while you're here? If you have fun at Fantasy Island Amusement Park, you'll love Thundering Surf Waterpark and Settler's Mill Adventure Golf, both a short walk away.

See properties

Surflight Theatre

8.0/10 (49 reviews)

Surflight Theatre is 2.3 mi (3.7 km) from central Beach Haven, why not stop by during your stay. Hotels.com travelers also say the area is family-friendly and has lots of nice beaches. If you want to experience more of the culture Beach Haven has to offer, head to Fantasy Island Amusement Park, Thundering Surf Waterpark, and Bay Village.

See properties

Frequently asked questions

What are the best hotels near Shelter Island?

Guests love staying at MGM Tower at Borgata, which is a resort near Shelter Island.
Nobu Hotel Atlantic City - A Caesars Rewards Destination is another well-reviewed hotel and is in the larger area.
With 5,883 hotels, vacation rentals, and other accommodations in the area, you'll have plenty to choose from.

How much does it cost to stay in a hotel near Shelter Island?

You can review prices on Hotels.com by entering your search criteria and sorting by price. Remember that rates vary based on where and when you plan to go.

Search for the lowest price per night from CNY917

Can I find hotels close to Shelter Island that are fully refundable?

Yes, many hotels offer refundable room reservations if you cancel prior to the cancellation deadline. Find refundable rates using the "Fully refundable" filter when you search for hotels.

Both MGM Tower at Borgata and Nobu Hotel Atlantic City - A Caesars Rewards Destination are highly rated hotels near Shelter Island that offer these rates.

What are the best romantic hotels near Shelter Island?

For a romantic stay, MGM Tower at Borgata offers 17 restaurants, an indoor pool, and 6 bars/lounges. It's within reach of Shelter Island.
Another great option is Borgata Hotel Casino & Spa, which is in the larger area.

What are the best hotels close to Shelter Island with free breakfast?

You can enjoy a free full breakfast at Mathis House, A Victorian Bed & Breakfast and Tea Room at 600 Main, which is within reach of Shelter Island.
Colonial Inn is also a recommended place to stay with a free full breakfast, and it's located in the larger area.

Which hotels near Shelter Island have rooms with great views?

Travelers can enjoy rooms with ocean or mountain views at Hard Rock Hotel & Casino Atlantic City, which is within reach of Shelter Island.
Also recommended is Seaview Hotel, which has rooms with courtyard views.

What are the best family hotels close to Shelter Island?

The entire family will enjoy a stay at Golden Nugget which offers children's meals, a seasonal outdoor pool, and an ocean-view restaurant. Shelter Island is in the larger area.
Another great option for your family's trip is Showboat Hotel Atlantic City.

What are the best luxury hotels near Shelter Island?

Pamper yourself with a stay at Borgata Hotel Casino & Spa, which is within reach of Shelter Island. This resort features 17 restaurants including Old Homestead Steak House, and offers an indoor pool.
Another luxe option is MGM Tower at Borgata, which is in the larger area.

What are the best hotels near Shelter Island with free parking?

If you're traveling by car, Seaview Hotel offers free parking and you'll be within reach of Shelter Island.
Another property that offers free parking is Golden Nugget, which is in the larger area.

What are the best hotels near Shelter Island with a pool?

Travelers can enjoy the indoor pool and seasonal outdoor pool at MGM Tower at Borgata. Shelter Island is within reach of the hotel.
Another great choice for a hotel with a pool is Nobu Hotel Atlantic City - A Caesars Rewards Destination.

What cheap motels can I book close to Shelter Island?

To save on your stay near Shelter Island, take a look at Sea Spray Motel, which offers a seasonal outdoor pool and a terrace.
Another inexpensive motel nearby to consider is Sea Horse Motel.

What are the best things to see and do around my hotel near Shelter Island?

You can check out sights near Shelter Island like Fantasy Island Amusement Park, Brant Beach, and Spray Beach.
Other places in the area are Bay Village and Edwin B. Forsythe National Wildlife Refuge.

What are the best lodges close to Shelter Island?

Appreciate the natural setting around Margate Summer Rental - 2 Blocks from the Beach, which is within reach of Shelter Island, and enjoy amenities such as a playground.

What are the best cabins close to Shelter Island?

Waterfront Bungalow nightly panoramic view of our illuminated covered Bridge: Enjoy rest, relaxation and a fireplace when you stay at this cabin located within reach of Shelter Island.
Shire House vibrant spacious cabin safe family pet friendly fire pit trails fish: Here's another cozy cabin to consider, which is in the larger area.

What are the best campsites near Shelter Island?

Lakeside Cottage Rental in Seasonal Campground: Experience a rural setting when you stay within reach of Shelter Island. This campsite offers guests a hot tub.

What are the best pet-friendly hotels close to Shelter Island?

Bring your cherished pet with you to Seaview Hotel, which is within reach of Shelter Island.
The Seahaus Hotel, Atlantic City Boardwalk, a Tribute Portfolio Hotel is another pet-friendly option.