Hotels near Whaley Lake Holmes

"We had an absolutely amazing stay! The property was fantastic, the room stupendous, the bathtub a god-send, and the property owner and staff were next level! Will recommend this to all of our friends, family, and strangers as THE place to go visit and stay!"

"Clean room, courteous staff"

"Beautiful property and comfortable accommodations!"

"The staff are amazing. They were very helpful & pleasant."

"We enjoyed a very nice stay, staff was friendly and helpful."

"Lots of coffee choices. Nice staff. Clean rooms. Beautiful view from our room of the stream/creek. "

"Clean room Jeremy was Great! Love that we can stay there with our dog!"

"Nice, clean place. Great friendly staff. The room we stayed in was not renovated as yet but still very clean. Would definitely stay there again."

"We wanted an overnight stay so as not to travel back to Long Island from upstate and also because it was our 51st Wedding Anniversary. In addition, we were going to Middletown the next day, June 1, 2026. This hotel was perfect in location and comfort. Accommodating and polite staff, clean and super comfortable bed, we slept very well. Satisfying breakfast especially the coffee. So we’d stay again and recommend It as well."

"Staff are so friendly. Very solid hotel. Great coffee in the lobby. "

"Clean and comfortable room, and excellent location for access to dining and shopping. I intend to stay here again in the future. "

"Friendly staff , large rooms . A bit outdated but clean and easy access"

"Staff was very courteous & helpful… room was spacious & very clean. Complementary breakfast was yummy & plentiful. Highly recommend."

"Clean room Friendly staff"

"The staff was nice and the room pretty nice, though it was a little noisy."

"Be sure to bring anything you need. No dishes, only toiletry is bar soap."